For each day, readings are listed which should be done before coming to class that day. Primary source readings (from ANT, CLA, or on-line) should also be brought to class to facilitate discussion. On-line readings can be found by clicking on the underlined assignment. Photocopied readings, which are available from the Blackboard site ([link removed]), are marked with an asterisk (*). You should also be able to click directly on the link (if you are logged in to iLearn) to get to the reading. [note: These links have been removed for the archived version of this website.]
For each days class, a list of topics and questions are provided to give some idea of the structure of that days lecture and discussion, and help students maximize their reading and class preparation. Recommended Readings, usually from Henry Chadwick's The Early Church, are also included below the day's questions
Readings from the two sourcebooks (ANT = After the New Testament; CLA = Christianity in Late Antiquity) are given according to the page numbers of these books, followed by more detailed citations (giving page numbers, Reading numbers, and Reading titles). Some entries will also have links labeled For more information... ; these links take you to web pages outside of these course website, and are not required, only recommended for those students who want more information to supplement their reading.
Mon. Apr. 2: Course Introduction Overview of course syllabus and requirements.
No readings
Wed. Apr. 4: Beginnings and Contexts: Jews, Gentiles, Romans, Christians What was the cultural and political context from which Christianity emerged? How did a small Jewish renewal movement become a mysterious cult in the Roman Empire? How did this movement appear to curious outsiders?
Readings
ANT, ch. 1: "General Introduction" (pp. 1-6) Earliest Roman sources on Christianity selections from Suetonius, Pliny the Younger, and Tacitus
For more information... on these ancient Roman authors, check their Wikipedia entries: Suetonius, Pliny, Tacitus
For more information... on the geographic spread of Christianity, check out this map
Recommended Readings: Henry Chadwick, The Early Church, 9-31
Fri. Apr. 6: Expansion and the Spread of Christianity How did the earliest Christians understand the expansion of their movement? What did they "sell" to potential converts, and how did they imagine their new movement fit into the world around them? How was their entry into the new community ritualized?
Readings
ANT, ch. 2: "The Spread of Christianity: Early Christians and their Converts"
ANT, ch. 11: "The Development of the Liturgy"
For more information... on the geographic spread of Christianity, check out this animated map.
Recommended Readings: Henry Chadwick, The Early Church, 54-66
Mon. Apr. 9: Christianity Under Attack: Persecution and Martyrdom Under what circumstances were some Christians tortured or put to death in the first centuries? When did texts about these martyrs begin to circulate, and why would Christians retell such gruesome stories of torture and death in their communities? What message about their own identity were they getting from such tales?
Readings
ANT, ch. 2: "The Spread of Christianity"
For more information... look at this map of the locations of some of the early martyrdoms.
Recommended Readings: Robert Wilken, The Christians as the Romans Saw Them, pp. 48-67
Wed. Apr. 11: Christianity on the Defensive: Apology Why were accusations of incest, cannibalism, and atheism lodged against Christians, and how did they defend themselves against these charges? Were apologies (legal defenses) aimed primarily at non-Christians, or do they make more sense as internal documents designed to encourage the faithful?
Readings
ANT, ch. 4: "The Defense of Christianity"
For more information... about the Roman Emperors to whom these "apologies" were addressed, view the capsule biographies on this site (check out Antoninus Pius, Lucius Verus, and Marcus Aurelius).
Recommended Readings: Robert Wilken, The Christians as the Romans Saw Them, pp. 94-125
Fri. Apr. 13: Diversity, I: Jews and/or Christians? Why did a predominantly gentile religious movement understand its Jewish originsand how did they negotiate the boundary between Jews and Christians? Why did some Christians refuse to acknowledge that boundary, while others found it to be so important?
Readings
ANT, ch. 5: "Anti-Judaic Polemic"
ANT, ch. 6: "The Diversity of Early Christianity"
For more information... on the history and development of Jewish-Christian relations, check out the resources at this site.
Recommended Readings: Henry Chadwick, The Early Church, 66-73
Mon. Apr. 16: Diversity, II: Gnosticism, Salvation from Another World Why did some Christians focus on abstract mythological themes of salvation from "out there"? Who were the "gnostics," and were their views of Christian salvation really so alien to "mainstream" Christianity? Was gnosticism the most purely "non-Jewish" form of Christianity?
Readings
ANT, ch. 6: "The Diversity of Early Christianity"
For more information... on Nag Hammadi and gnostic texts and beliefs, look through this website on Gnosticism.
Recommended Readings: Henry Chadwick, The Early Church, 33-41
Wed. Apr. 18: From Text to Canon: Forming a "New" Testament How and why did early Christians select some texts for inclusion in a new, canonical set of Scriptures, and what purposes did this "new" testament serve? What texts were excluded, and what can we learn about the diversity of early Christianity(ies) from them?
Readings
ANT, ch. 8: "'Apostolic' Writings Outside the Canon"
ANT, ch. 9: "The New Scriptures"
Recommended Readings: Henry Chadwick, The Early Church, 41-45
Fri. Apr. 20: Ritual and Office: Building the "Church" How did Christian communities organize themselves through institution and ritual? What were "bishops," "presbyters," and "deacons," and why did some Christians (but not all) think they were so important?
Readings
ANT, ch. 10: "The Structure of Early Christianity"
ANT, ch. 11: "'The Development of the Liturgy"
Recommended Readings: Henry Chadwick, The Early Church, 45-53
Mon. Apr. 23: Controversies: Fractures in the Church In what manner did different Christian communities begin to become divided, and attempt to reach consensus, on various internal issues, such as ritual, morality, Trinity, and divinity? How did the Marcionites and Montanists bring these issues to a head, and how did Tertullian come to speak to so many of these internal fractures?
Readings
ANT, ch. 7: "The Internal Conflicts of Christianity"
ANT, ch. 13: "Leading the Upright Life"
ANT, ch. 14: "The Emergence of Orthodoxy"
For more information... look at this map of the "founders" of major early Christian heresies.
Recommended Readings: Henry Chadwick, The Early Church, 52-53 (on Montanism), 84-93
essay #1 due at the beginning of class
Wed. Apr. 25: Intellectuals: Clement and Origen How did Christians begin to incorporate high culture into their understanding of theology, ethics, and biblical interpretation? What contributions did educated thinkers such as Clement of Alexandria and Origen make in integrating philosophy into Christian faith?
Readings
ANT, ch. 13: "Leading the Upright Life"
ANT, ch. 12: "The Proclamation of the Word"
ANT, ch. 14: "The Emergence of Orthodoxy"
Recommended Readings: Henry Chadwick, The Early Church, 94-113
Fri. Apr. 27: Philosophers: A New Culture War As Christianity became more intellectual, how did pagan critics respond through defenses of Greek philosophy and culture? What do the criticisms of Celsus (second century) and Porphyry (third century) tell us about the sophistication of Christianity, and its perceived threat to traditional Greco-Roman religion?
Readings
ANT, ch. 4: "The Defense of Christianity"
* Porphyry: The Most Learned Critic of Them All, from Robert Wilken, Christians as the Romans Saw Them, pp. 126-63 (on reserve in Rivera Library, and also available in PDF form through the Blackboard site [click on "Assignments" button]).
Mon. Apr. 30: The End of Persecution Under what circumstances did Roman Emperors attempt to root out Christianity in the third and fourth centuries, and what sort of threat did Christianity pose to state religion in times of political turmoil and reconstruction? What consequences did these systematic persecutions have on debates over morality and authority within the Christian churches? How, and why, did the persecutions stop?
Readings
CLA, ch. 1: "General Introduction" (pp. 1-7)
CLA, ch. 2: "The End of Persecution"
Recommended Readings: ANT 340-42, 430-35; Henry Chadwick, The Early Church, 116-124
Wed. May 2: Constantine: Church as State? What was the significance of Constantine the Greats conversion to Christianity and his subsequent patronage of Christian churches? Was this a radical shift in religious and political relations? What changes did Constantine make to laws, politics, and economics, and how did his later biographers view this conversion and its effect on the Empire?
Readings
CLA, ch. 3: "Christianity and the Imperial House"
CLA, ch. 4: "Christianity and Roman Law"
For more information... about the first Christian Roman Emperors, read the capsule biographies on this site (check out Constantine I especially).
Recommended Readings:
Henry Chadwick, The Early Church, 125-129 Fri. May 4: Nicaea: State and Church What theological disputes led to the imperial convocation of a world-wide Christian council in Nicaea in 325? What were the teachings of Arius, and why were they condemned? What role did philosophy and Scriptures play in these debates, and what was actually decided at Nicaea?
Readings
CLA, ch. 7: "Heresy and Orthodoxy"
CLA, ch. 8: "Canons and Creeds"
For more information... view this map of the major "ecumenical councils" in late antiquity.
Recommend Readings: Henry Chadwick, The Early Church, 113-116, 130-132
Mon. May 7: MIDTERM
Wed. May 9: Trinity: Theological Debate after Nicaea How did conflicts over the Triune God evolve after Nicaea? What role did regional, metropolitan, and imperial politics play in the theological debates, and what forms of discipline were used against dissenters? What role did major bishops--the Cappadocians and Athanasius--play in the conflict, and what exactly got resolved in Constantinople in 381?
Readings
CLA, ch. 7: "Heresy and Orthodoxy"
CLA, ch. 8, "Canons and Creeds"
Recommended Readings: Henry Chadwick, The Early Church, 133-151
Fri. May 11: Julian: Pagans and Culture How were cultural, political, and ethnic crises within Christianity worsened by the attempts of Julian, the last non-Christian emperor, to revive pagan religion? What were the consequences of Julians failed religious revival? How did Christians learn to adapt paideia (classical education) to religious faith?
Readings
CLA, ch. 3: "Christianity and the Imperial House"
CLA, ch. 12: "The Christian Bible"
* "Julian the Apostate: Jewish Law and Christian Truth," Robert Wilken, Christians as the Romans Saw Them, pp. 164-196 (on reserve in Rivera Library, and also available in PDF form through the Blackboard site [click on "Assignments" button]).
For more information... about "Julian the Apostate," check out this surprisingly accurate and readable novel by Gore Vidal.
Recommended Readings: Henry Chadwick, The Early Church, 152-159
Mon. May 14: Bishops: Preaching, Conflict, and Violence in Christian Cities How did the political, economic, and religious role of the bishop evolve after Constantine, especially in urban centers (such as Milan, Constantinople, and Alexandria)? Why were some bishops (Ambrose, John Chrysostom, Theophilus) such magnets for controversy?
Readings
CLA, ch. 3: "Christianity and the Imperial House"
CLA, ch. 6: "Christian Leadership"
CLA, ch. 7: "Heresy and Orthodoxy"
Recommended Readings: Henry Chadwick, The Early Church, 160-173, 184-191
Wed. May 16: Asceticism, part I: Holiness in the Desert Why did some individuals begin to withdraw from society and pursue rigorous physical denial in the deserts of Egypt? What can we know about the origins of Christian monasticism from our surviving sources (the Life of Antony, the Rule of Pachomius), and what do they tell us about new ideals of Christian salvation?
Readings
CLA, ch. 9: "Asceticism and Monasticism"
CLA, ch. 11: "Saints's Lives"
Recommended Readings: Henry Chadwick, The Early Church, 174-183
Fri. May 18: Asceticism, part II: The Sanctity of the Body What philosophical, medical, and religious concepts lay behind the rise of Christian self-discipline (asceticism), and what kinds of monks came to exist in the fourth and fifth centuries? What broader issues--on salvation, authority, and gender--were at play in the diverse ascetic movements?
Readings
CLA, ch. 9: "Asceticism and Monasticism"
CLA, ch. 11: "Saints' Lives"
Mon. May 21: Pilgrimage: Landscapes of Faith Why did some Christians begin to venerate objects and places, particularly the bones of saints and the sites of the holy land? How did the rise of pilgrimage relate to asceticism and imperial politics, and what theological disputes surrounded this new practice?
Readings
CLA, ch. 10: "Pilgrims, Relics, and Holy Places"
For more information... on pilgrimage to the holy land, check out this site (still under construction).
Wed. May 23: Saints: The Mirror of Holy Lives What value did ascetic and nonascetic Christians find in the literary pastiche of saints lives? Were these literal models of imitation, escapist fantasy reading, or did they convey more subtle religious themes? How was an everyday Christian supposed to relate to an ex-prostitute, cross-dressing hermit?
Readings
CLA, ch. 11: "Saints' Lives"
Fri. May 25: Jerome and Augustine: Personhood and Salvation How did Latin theology focus on the role of human participation in salvation, grace, free will, and evil? How did Jerome and Augustine come to dominate these controversies, and what were their lasting legacies (cultural, political, and religious) to Western Christianity?
Readings
CLA, ch. 5: "Becoming a Christian"
CLA, ch. 7: "Heresy and Orthodoxy"
Recommended Readings: Henry Chadwick, The Early Church, 213-236
Mon. May 28: No class (Memorial Day)
Wed. May 30: Community and Boundaries How did the post-Constantinian church define and enforce the boundaries with "others" (especially Jews, "Jewish-Christians," and other varieties of heretics)? How did imperial force come to be deployed in the resolution of the "Donatist schism," and what impact did this have on theologies of self, community, and church?
Readings
CLA, ch. 7: "Heresy and Orthodoxy"
essay #2 due at the beginning of class
Fri. June 1: Christology: Theological Debate in the Fifth Century What were the political and theological dimensions of the debate between Cyril and Nestorius over the nature of Christ, and what role did imperial politics in Rome and Constantinople play? What was decided at the councils of Ephesus and Chalcedon, and what was controversies about God and salvation remained unresolved?
Readings
CLA, ch. 7: "Heresy and Orthodoxy"
CLA, ch. 8: "Canons and Creeds"
Recommended Readings: Henry Chadwick, The Early Church, 192-212
Mon. June 4: Expressions, I: Bible, Canon, and Interpretation How did the Bible--its words, canonical shape, and interpretation--shape the formation of Christian "culture" in the fourth century and beyond? How did "apocrypha" become synonymous with "heresy," and how did sophisticated biblical interpretation mediate between Christian simplicity and philosophical ideas?
Readings
CLA, ch. 12: "The Christian Bible"
Recommended Readings: CLA 440-455
Wed. June 6: Expressions, II: Early Christian Art and Ritual How did the performance of Christian identity transform ritual and urban spaces into a dramatic theater of salvation? What particular architectural and artistic forms evolved to express and encode Christianity in late antiquity?
Readings
CLA, ch. 5: "Becoming a Christian"
CLA, ch. 6: "Christian Leadership"
CLA, ch. 13: "Christian Art and Architecture"
Recommended Readings: Henry Chadwick, The Early Church, 258-284
Fri. June 9: Barbarians and Conclusions How did Christianity reach the peoples outside of the Roman Empire: northern Europe, Africa, and Asia? What did Christianity look like as the Roman Empire collapsed in the fifth and sixth centuries? Also, any final questions from the class.
Readings
CLA, ch. 14: "Christianity Outside the Roman Empire"
Recommended Readings: 247-257, 285-290
FINAL EXAM: THURSDAY, JUNE 14, 2007, 11:30AM - 2:30PM |
Illustration: Alessandro Botticelli, "Saint Augustine" (1480)